The Real Reason Your Jewelry Isn't as Durable as You Think

October 15, 2024

Jewelry has always been more than just a fashion statement. For many, it holds deep sentimental value, symbolizing significant moments in life—like engagement rings, family heirlooms, or gifts from loved ones. It can also represent personal style, a way to express individuality. But whether a piece is vintage or brand new, jewelry is not immune to wear and tear.

Many people assume that because fine jewelry is made of precious metals and gemstones, it will last forever without any special care. While high-quality materials are chosen for their beauty and durability, they are not indestructible. Just like anything else that is worn daily or regularly exposed to the elements, jewelry can suffer from damage and degradation over time. Without proper attention, even the most robust pieces can lose their luster or become damaged.

Understanding why jewelry can be delicate, despite its often sturdy appearance, is key to preserving its beauty and integrity. From physical impacts to environmental exposure, several factors can affect your jewelry’s condition. This is why knowing how to properly care for your pieces is essential. In this guide, we’ll explore why jewelry is not invincible and provide helpful tips on how to maintain it, so you can enjoy your treasures for years to come.

Why Jewelry Isn’t Indestructible

Despite being crafted from strong materials like gold, silver, platinum, and gemstones, jewelry is still vulnerable to damage from daily wear and environmental factors. Even precious metals, often seen as resilient, are not immune to wear. To improve their strength, jewelers frequently alloy these metals with other elements to make them more durable.

Gold: Pure gold (24k) is too soft for most jewelry use. To make it harder, gold is alloyed with other metals such as copper, silver, or palladium. This not only enhances its strength but also creates the various shades of gold (yellow, white, and rose). While these alloys improve gold's durability, they do not make it immune to scratches, dents, or bending, especially in higher karat pieces like 18k gold.
Silver: Sterling silver is another precious metal often used in jewelry, and like gold, pure silver is too soft for most jewelry designs. Sterling silver (92.5% silver, 7.5% copper or other metals) is a stronger version designed to resist bending and scratching. However, it remains prone to tarnishing over time, requiring regular maintenance.
Platinum: While platinum is considered one of the toughest metals in jewelry, even this durable metal can wear down over time. Platinum is often alloyed with small amounts of other metals to make it more workable, but its dense, heavy nature makes it less prone to bending or scratching compared to gold. Yet, with daily wear, platinum can still develop a patina, a soft sheen that some owners love but others may want to polish out.

The Mohs Hardness Scale

When it comes to gemstones, the Mohs Hardness Scale is an important tool for understanding their durability. Developed by mineralogist Friedrich Mohs in 1812, this scale ranks minerals based on their ability to resist scratching, with a scale of 1 to 10. Here’s a quick overview:

1 - Talc: The softest mineral, easily scratched with a fingernail.
2 - Gypsum: Slightly harder than talc, still can be scratched by a fingernail.
3 - Calcite: Can be scratched by a copper penny.
4 - Fluorite: Can be scratched by a nail.
5 - Apatite: Harder than fluorite, but still relatively soft.
6 - Orthoclase Feldspar: Can be scratched by a steel file.
7 - Quartz: A common gemstone that can scratch glass.
8 - Topaz: A durable gemstone often used in jewelry.
9 - Corundum: Includes sapphires and rubies, very hard and resistant to scratching.
10 - Diamond: The hardest natural material, resistant to scratches from all other substances.

Understanding where a gemstone falls on the Mohs scale can help you gauge how to care for it. For example, diamonds (10) are incredibly durable and can withstand daily wear, while softer stones like turquoise (5-6) or opals (5-6) require more delicate handling and care.

Common Reasons for Jewelry Damage

Here are the key factors that lead to jewelry degradation:

Physical Damage: Even the hardest gemstones, like diamonds, can chip, crack, or scratch if hit with enough force. Softer gemstones are especially vulnerable. For instance, pearls and opals, which fall lower on the Mohs scale, can scratch or chip easily if subjected to rough handling.
Environmental Exposure: Jewelry interacts with harmful elements like water, chemicals, and air. Tarnishing, discoloration, or corrosion can occur when pieces come into contact with chlorine, household cleaners, or even excessive sweat.
Heat and Light: Prolonged exposure to direct sunlight can fade or weaken gemstones such as amethyst or topaz. Similarly, extreme temperatures can cause metals like silver or certain stones to expand or contract, leading to cracks or loosening of settings.
Everyday Wear and Tear: Rings, bracelets, and necklaces that are worn daily endure friction and contact with various surfaces, which over time causes scratching, loosening of clasps or settings, and wear on delicate chains or engravings.

Essential Tips for Jewelry Care

Now that we know jewelry can be fragile, it’s time to look at how you can best take care of it. Here are some practical tips to keep your pieces sparkling and intact:

Store Properly Always store your jewelry in a cool, dry place, preferably in a fabric-lined jewelry box or individual pouches to avoid scratching. Storing pieces separately is important to prevent them from rubbing against each other. For delicate necklaces, use hooks to hang them to prevent tangling.
Remove Jewelry Before Certain Activities Avoid wearing jewelry when swimming, exercising, or cleaning. Chlorine, sweat, and harsh cleaning agents can tarnish metals and dull gemstones. Taking off your rings before engaging in any activity where they may be exposed to heavy impacts or pressure is also crucial for preventing physical damage.
Regular Cleaning and Maintenance Cleaning your jewelry regularly is essential to maintaining its shine. For metals like gold and platinum, a soft cloth and warm, soapy water can work wonders. You can gently scrub with a soft-bristle toothbrush to clean intricate details or hard-to-reach areas. Avoid harsh cleaners, especially for softer stones like pearls and opals. It’s also a good idea to have your jewelry professionally cleaned and inspected at least once a year to ensure that settings and prongs remain secure.
Avoid Exposure to Chemicals Chemicals in perfumes, lotions, hairsprays, and even everyday household cleaners can damage or discolor precious metals and stones. It’s best to apply these products before putting on your jewelry to avoid any direct contact.
Take Off Jewelry When Sleeping While it may be tempting to keep your rings or necklaces on at night, sleeping in jewelry can result in accidental damage. Chains can tangle, and rings can bend or break if they get caught on bedding or while you toss and turn.
Be Cautious with Light and Heat Keep your jewelry away from prolonged exposure to direct sunlight or extreme heat, which can weaken certain stones. Store them in a dark place when not in use to protect the vibrancy of gemstones.

Special Care for Different Materials

Gold: While gold is durable, it's relatively soft compared to other metals. Regular cleaning with a mild detergent will keep it bright. Avoid wearing gold pieces in water, as prolonged exposure can lead to tarnishing.
Silver: Sterling silver can tarnish quickly if not taken care of. A silver polishing cloth can restore shine, but it’s best to store silver pieces in airtight bags to slow tarnishing.
Gemstones: Different stones require different care. Diamonds, for example, are very durable, but softer stones like emeralds, opals, and pearls need more delicate handling. Never use abrasive materials to clean them.
Pearls: Pearls are especially sensitive to chemicals, heat, and moisture. Wipe them down with a soft cloth after wearing to remove oils and dirt. Store them separately to avoid scratching their soft surface.

Jewelry is not just a collection of precious materials—it’s a representation of memories, milestones, and personal style. While we might expect these treasured pieces to last forever, the reality is that jewelry, even the finest, is not indestructible. Metals can bend or tarnish, gemstones can scratch or chip, and settings can loosen over time. But with the right care, you can significantly extend the life of your jewelry and keep it looking just as beautiful as the day you first wore it.

The good news is that caring for your jewelry doesn’t require a lot of time or expensive products—just a few mindful habits. By storing your pieces properly, avoiding exposure to harsh chemicals, and cleaning them regularly, you’ll be taking important steps to prevent damage and preserve their shine. Whether it's remembering to take off your ring before going to the gym or storing your favorite necklace in a soft pouch, small actions can have a big impact on the longevity of your collection.

In addition to routine cleaning and careful handling, don’t forget the importance of professional maintenance. Having your jewelry inspected by a jeweler periodically ensures that prongs, clasps, and settings remain secure, helping to prevent any tragic losses or damage.

Ultimately, taking care of your jewelry is about recognizing its fragility and respecting its craftsmanship. These pieces are designed to be cherished for a lifetime—and perhaps beyond—but they need your help to remain in excellent condition. By practicing mindful care, you can ensure that your favorite pieces continue to shine and sparkle, whether you’re wearing them daily or passing them down to future generations.

So remember, your jewelry is a reflection of your life’s most meaningful moments. Protect it, care for it, and it will reward you with beauty that endures the test of time.

Back to blog